The Corporate Kabuki: Why Your Performance Review is Working
The cursor blinks. It’s a rhythmic, mocking pulse against the white expanse of the ‘Self-Assessment’ box on the HR portal. I’ve been staring at it for exactly 27 minutes, the same amount of time it took me this morning to fail utterly at folding a fitted sheet-a task that, much like this performance review, seems to possess no discernible corners and ends in a wadded-up ball of frustration. My manager, Dave, is likely doing the same thing three cubicles over. He’s trying to remember what I actually did 7 months ago, back when the heating was still broken and we all wore scarves to the morning stand-up. He can’t remember. I can’t remember. Yet, here we are, participating in the most elaborate piece of fiction since the last tax filing.
Quantifying the Soul
We tell ourselves these reviews are for ‘growth.’ We use words that feel heavy and important, like ‘synergy’ or ‘cross-functional impact,’ but we’re really just filling out Form 47-B to ensure the gears of the machine don’t grind to a halt.
There is a specific kind of hollowness that comes from trying to quantify a human soul into a 1-to-5 scale. If you’re a 4, you’re ‘exceeding expectations,’ but not so much that you’re entitled to a promotion. If you’re a 3, you’re the invisible glue holding the department